Searching for the best eyeliner ever ?!

Why You’ll Love It (From Maybelline website)
Only our oil-free formula can hold highly concentrated pigments in a clear gel base.
So color is more intense and lines resist wear for 24 hours.
Smudge-proof and Water-proof.
The most intense line for lasting drama.
Directions to use:

DEFINED LOOK – Define–yuu in small strokes, glide liner across lash line from inner to outer corner
DRAMATIC LOOK – Define– in small strokes, glide liner across lash line from inner to outer corner
Enhance – extend and thicken line from outer corner up towards brow; wing out for extra drama
Removes easily with soap and water or with Maybelline New York Expert Eyes Eye Makeup Remover Towelettes.
The tub-
The tub is small… It contains 2.8 g of product. The tub is good but the lid is very cheap aluminum foil thin.

The product-

The long wearing creamy gel texture provides the desired intense lines with a smooth, even application. (Pack info)
The gel is really creamy. Glides on real smooth.
The texture is creamier than a gel.